Nowadays every employer has to be
an “equal opportunity employer.” And
rightfully so. After all, our society was
founded on the basic principle that all
men are created equal.
Under our current laws, an employer
may not deny employment to any individual
based on race, sex, national
origin, religion, age or disability. To
avoid a charge of discrimination, the
employer must ensure that all aspects
of the pre-employment process are nondiscriminatory.
That task sounds easy
enough in theory. However, it’s not so
easy in practice.
In hiring, employers universally rely
on questions that people answer on job
application forms and in interviews. The
employer must be careful in choosing
the right questions. Many questions that
once were typically asked are now taboo.
Any question that could be viewed
as discriminatory can lead to trouble.
The fact that the employer meant no
harm is not a defense.
To illustrate this point, I have provided
some “don’t ask” questions. I have
also added some questions that can be
asked to obtain useful information in
the right way:
■ Don’t ask applicants about their
sex. Rather, ask if they have the physical
ability to perform all of the job duties of
the employment position.
■ Don’t ask about their religious
affiliation or their affiliations with
other organizations, clubs, societies,
etc. Rather, ask if they belong to any organization
that would prevent them from performing all of the job duties on the days
and hours of the employment position.
■ Don’t ask their age or date of
birth. Rather, ask if they are old enough to
carry out the job duties — i.e., old enough
to drive or serve alcoholic beverages.
■ Don’t ask about their medical
history or whether they have physical
conditions, impairments or disabilities. Rather, ask if they have the mental
and physical ability to fully and properly
perform all of the job duties listed.
■ Don’t ask about their marital
status or whether they have children. Rather, ask if they can work all of the
days and hours of the employment position.
■ Don’t ask if they have been arrested. Rather, ask if they were convicted of
a felony, and the disposition of that conviction.
One more thing. If an employer uses
a third party to conduct a background
check, he or she must comply with the
provisions under the federal Fair Credit
Reporting Act. Employers rely on consumer
reports and investigation reports
in this process, and the act requires
them to tell employees about these background
checks.
Charges of discrimination are relatively
easy to make and can be expensive
to defend. All employers are urged
to review their pre-employment process
to ensure compliance with current law.
Since discrimination law is complicated,
the services of a attorney could be
very beneficial.
Tom Keuler has been a partner in
Paducah’s Denton & Keuler law firm
for more than 30 years. He represents
many of the firm’s commercial,
industrial and banking clients,
and has been special counsel to
the City of Paducah and counsel to
the Municipal Code Commission in Frankfort.
Printed in Four Rivers Business Journal (Paducah Sun), July 2008 |